the death note movie was... ... ... basically i think the director was an idiot. to the people who had never read the manga, its a pretty good show; there's suspense, there's this showdown between two people, and the detective is a genius.
but it was just lacking in what death note was all about: the battle of wits between TWO geniuses. plus the 'pull' factor that keeps all death note fans glued to the series: the audiences are clever enough to see two steps in advance; but the two geniuses are always one step ahead, continously surprising us with their insight and ingenuity.
and the director seems intent on showing us just how stupid he thinks commoners are. apparently, his take on the NPA is that the higher up detectives and analysts had never done statistics before, and that the audience would just be woo-ed when he adds in some hocus pocus statistics, graphs and studies that don't really impact the investigation.
to those who had watched the movie and are currently thinking "duh. that's quite an average detective show" i'm gonna bring some justice to the original MANGA. if you'd not watched the movie, or think 'the movie's just fine!' move along now~ there's nothing for you here.
make your decision. are you reading on? (warning: spoilers ahead)
1) movie: light was this very naive college student who tot that the law was perfect, and went looking for trouble just to see for himself the loophole in the law system, and became very depressed. his gf was just as naive. -___-
> manga: light was a genius who knew that society had many flaws that simple law and order is unable to right. he's an idealist who believes that law-abiding citizens should enjoy a civilized society.
2) movie: light confronted Raye in front of his gf, accusing him of tailing him. hence the gf knew that there was a connection between light and the FBI, Raye.
> manga: of coz light did not confront Raye. as light's tail, he would predictably sit behind them such that the plan would still work perfectly.
3) movie: naomi was an idiot, divulging personal information and background. rawrgh!
>manga: she was really smart, being able to draw conclusions with what little info she had. she was just unfortunate she didn't know Raye was tailing Light, and hence fell victim to him. Light only realized she had given him a false name minutes before she was going to turn in her findings to the station, and had to try to lure her name out.
4) movie: light killed his gf so he would have an excuse to get into the investigation team.
> manga: well~ he got into the team coz of L's initiative. i guess that's a little planning ahead by light... just that it was very evil, very self-damaging, and very uncharacteristic of him.
and yadar yardar....